7 ChatGPT Alternativen für Entwickler - Erfahrungen und Bewertungen

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. The Rise of AI-powered Tools for Developers
   • 2.1 GitHub Co-Pilot
   • 2.2 ChatGPT-3
   • 2.3 ChatGPT-4
   • 2.4 ChatGPT-3.5
   • 2.5 ChatSonic
   • 2.6 Code Whisper
   • 2.7 Ask Code
   • 2.8 Bing Chat
   • 2.9 Bricks
   • 2.10 Compiler
3. The Traveling Salesperson Problem
   • 3.1 Definition of the Problem
   • 3.2 Different Approaches to Solving the Problem
4. AI Tools for Solving the Traveling Salesperson Problem
   • 4.1 Testing with Four Cities
     • 4.1.1 ChatGPT-3
     • 4.1.2 ChatGPT-3.5
     • 4.1.3 ChatSonic
     • 4.1.4 Compiler
   • 4.2 Testing with Twenty Cities
     • 4.2.1 ChatGPT-3
     • 4.2.2 ChatGPT-3.5
     • 4.2.3 ChatSonic
     • 4.2.4 Compiler
5. Rankings and Recommendations
6. Conclusion

The Rise of AI-powered Tools for Developers

In recent years, AI-powered tools have become increasingly popular among developers. These tools offer a range of benefits, from enhancing productivity to providing smart autocomplete suggestions. One such tool that gained significant Attention is GitHub Co-Pilot. However, the landscape changed when ChatGPT-4 and other alternatives entered the market.

The Traveling Salesperson Problem

The traveling salesperson problem (TSP) is a classic optimization problem in computer science. The objective is to find the shortest possible route that allows a salesperson to visit a set of cities and return to the starting point. As the number of cities increases, the problem becomes exponentially more complex, making it an ideal benchmark for testing AI tools.

AI Tools for Solving the Traveling Salesperson Problem

To evaluate the performance of various AI tools, a test was conducted using two scenarios: one with four cities and another with twenty cities. The tested tools include ChatGPT-3, ChatGPT-3.5, ChatSonic, and Compiler.

4.1 Testing with Four Cities

4.1.1 ChatGPT-3

ChatGPT-3 performed well in solving the TSP with four cities. The generated code accurately calculated the shortest distance between the cities.

4.1.2 ChatGPT-3.5

ChatGPT-3.5 also provided a correct solution for the four-city TSP. The code generated by the tool efficiently calculated the shortest path.

4.1.3 ChatSonic

ChatSonic successfully solved the TSP with four cities, offering a concise and readable solution. The code provided by ChatSonic accurately found the shortest distance.

4.1.4 Compiler

Compiler, an AI Tool integrated into VS Code, demonstrated its capability to solve the TSP with four cities. Although the process was challenging and required additional modifications, the tool ultimately produced the correct solution.

4.2 Testing with Twenty Cities

4.2.1 ChatGPT-3

When tested with twenty cities, ChatGPT-3 failed to provide an accurate solution. The generated code did not result in the shortest distance.

4.2.2 ChatGPT-3.5

ChatGPT-3.5 also fell short in solving the TSP with twenty cities. The generated code did not yield the optimal path.

4.2.3 ChatSonic

ChatSonic's solution for the twenty-city TSP was impressive. The tool's code utilized the nearest neighbor algorithm and produced a round-trip solution, achieving the goal of finding the shortest distance.

4.2.4 Compiler

Compiler showcased its ability to handle complex algorithms in solving the twenty-city TSP. The generated code successfully generated a round-trip solution, effectively minimizing the distance traveled.

Rankings and Recommendations

Considering readability, performance, and accuracy, the following rankings were given to the tested AI tools:

1. ChatSonic
2. ChatGPT-3.5
3. ChatGPT-3
4. Compiler

Based on these rankings, it is recommended to use ChatSonic and ChatGPT-3.5 as free alternatives and consider Compiler as a paid option for more complex projects.

Conclusion

AI-powered tools have revolutionized the development process, offering developers new ways to enhance their productivity and efficiency. While AI tools like GitHub Co-Pilot may have limitations, alternatives like ChatSonic, ChatGPT-3.5, and Compiler prove to be valuable assets for developers tackling optimization problems like the traveling salesperson problem.

FAQ:

Q: Which AI tool performed the best in solving the traveling salesperson problem? A: Among the tested tools, ChatSonic stood out as the best performer for both the four-city and twenty-city scenarios.

Q: Is GitHub Co-Pilot still a reliable tool for developers? A: Reports and evaluations suggest that GitHub Co-Pilot's accuracy and code quality have decreased over time. It is advisable to consider alternative tools for development tasks.

Q: Are there any AI tools that are free to use? A: Yes, there are free AI tools available such as ChatGPT-3.5, ChatSonic, and Compiler (with a free tier). These tools can assist developers in solving complex problems without incurring additional costs.

Q: What criteria were used to rank the AI tools? A: The rankings were based on the readability of the generated code and the accuracy of the solutions provided by the AI tools.

Q: Can AI tools completely replace human developers? A: AI tools are designed to support and augment developers' work, but they cannot completely replace the expertise and creativity of human developers. Human involvement is still crucial for complex problem-solving and critical decision-making.