Choosing the Perfect Snorkel Mask: Full Face vs. Old Style

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction
2. Comfort 2.1 Benefits of Full Face Snorkel Masks 2.2 Discomforts of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 2.3 Conclusion
3. Reliability 3.1 Concerns with Full Face Snorkel Masks 3.2 Benefits of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 3.3 Conclusion
4. Utility and Usefulness 4.1 Limitations of Full Face Snorkel Masks 4.2 Versatility of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 4.3 Conclusion
5. Safety 5.1 Safety Concerns with Full Face Snorkel Masks 5.2 Safety Advantages of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 5.3 Conclusion
6. Price 6.1 Cost of Full Face Snorkel Masks 6.2 Cost of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 6.3 Conclusion
7. Coolness Factor 7.1 Perception of Full Face Snorkel Masks 7.2 Perception of Traditional Masks and Snorkels 7.3 Conclusion
8. Conclusion
9. FAQs

Full Face Snorkel Masks vs Traditional Masks and Snorkels: Which is Better?

Introduction

Snorkeling enthusiasts often find themselves in a dilemma when choosing between a full face snorkel mask and a traditional mask and snorkel. Both options have their merits and demerits, but deciding which one is better can be a difficult task. In this article, we will compare the two types of snorkeling gear, exploring their comfort levels, reliability, utility, safety aspects, price, and even the coolness factor associated with them. By the end, You'll have a better understanding of which option suits your needs best.

Comfort

Comfort plays a crucial role when it comes to enjoying a snorkeling experience. Full face snorkel masks offer several advantages in terms of comfort. Firstly, these masks keep Water off your face, including your lips. This ensures that your lips do not dry out due to saltwater exposure. Additionally, there is no water seeping into your mouth, providing a pleasant snorkeling experience. Unlike traditional masks and snorkels, full face masks do not require a mouthpiece, eliminating jaw fatigue. The straps on full face snorkel masks are often made of stretchy cloth material, providing an overall comfortable fit. Moreover, these masks rarely fog up, thanks to the continuous airflow, preventing the annoyance faced by traditional mask users. However, it is important to note that some discomforts come with using traditional masks and snorkels, such as jaw fatigue from prolonged use and saltwater leakage around the nose area.

Reliability

When it comes to reliability, concerns arise with full face snorkel masks. These masks rely on various internal components, such as one-way valves and the absence of fogging upon inhaling. Failure of any of these parts can lead to potentially dangerous situations, including rebreathing one's exhaled air and oxygen depletion. Additionally, the large viewing window on full face masks is more prone to scratching, affecting visibility. On the other HAND, traditional masks and snorkels have simpler designs. They consist of separate mask and snorkel components, allowing for individual use and providing a level of redundancy. The smaller lens size and tempered Glass construction of traditional masks make them both Durable and less prone to scratches. Overall, traditional masks and snorkels have proven to be more reliable over time.

Utility and Usefulness

The utility and usefulness of snorkeling gear are important factors to consider. Full face snorkel masks are primarily designed for surface snorkeling and are not suitable for diving deep underwater. The one-way valves in these masks prevent equalization, making them uncomfortable when diving down. Their buoyancy also makes it challenging to dive deeper. In contrast, traditional masks and snorkels are versatile. They can be used for snorkeling, scuba diving, and free diving. With a traditional mask, you can keep it on your face while removing the snorkel to communicate freely with your dive buddy or others. Traditional masks are also easy to store and convenient for travel purposes, making them a popular choice.

Safety

Safety is a vital aspect to consider when snorkeling. Full face snorkel masks come with certain safety concerns. Improper fitting can lead to water leakage around the mouth and nose, compromising breathing and increasing the risk of water intake. In case of flooding, removing a full face mask takes longer than removing a traditional mask, potentially causing panic or distress. With a traditional mask and snorkel, clearing water from the snorkel is a simple process, either by blowing it out or spitting it out. Moreover, traditional masks and snorkels allow for easily removing the snorkel to regain airflow if needed. Therefore, in terms of safety, traditional masks and snorkels have proven to be a more reliable choice.

Price

Price is undoubtedly an important consideration for many snorkelers. Full face snorkel masks tend to vary in price, with cheaper options starting from around $29 online. However, for a safe and reliable brand, prices typically start from $60. Comparatively, traditional masks and snorkels are relatively more affordable, starting from around $25 online. Good quality brands of traditional masks can be found for approximately $50 online. For those on a budget, traditional masks and snorkels offer a more cost-effective option.

Coolness Factor

While the coolness factor may not be the primary concern for snorkelers, it can impact how others perceive them. Full face snorkel masks are often associated with beginners or newbies in the snorkeling world. Some snorkel tour operators, particularly in Hawaii, do not allow these masks on their boats. On the other hand, traditional masks and snorkels are considered more accepted and preferred by experienced snorkelers. Therefore, opting for a traditional mask and snorkel can help Create a better impression and ensure a warm welcome on snorkel tours.

Conclusion

After carefully considering the comfort, reliability, utility, safety, price, and coolness factor, it is evident that traditional masks and snorkels outshine full face snorkel masks in most aspects. Traditional masks offer better reliability, versatility, and safety, making them a popular choice among snorkelers. While full face snorkel masks can be beneficial for those with physical limitations, they should not be regarded as a superior option. It is crucial to prioritize safety and reliability when making a decision. So, whether you're a beginner or an experienced snorkeler, investing in a traditional mask and snorkel will provide you with a more enjoyable and reliable snorkeling experience.

FAQs

Q: Are full face snorkel masks more comfortable than traditional masks and snorkels? A: Full face snorkel masks offer a higher level of comfort as they keep water off your face, prevent fogging, and eliminate the need for a mouthpiece. However, traditional masks and snorkels also provide comfort, minus the potential jaw fatigue.

Q: Can full face snorkel masks be used for diving? A: Full face snorkel masks are not suitable for diving due to their design limitations, particularly in terms of equalization and buoyancy. They are primarily intended for surface snorkeling.

Q: Are traditional masks and snorkels more reliable than full face snorkel masks? A: Yes, traditional masks and snorkels are generally more reliable. Full face snorkel masks have more internal components that can fail, potentially leading to dangerous situations. Traditional masks have simpler designs and are made with durable materials.

Q: What is the price difference between full face snorkel masks and traditional masks? A: Full face snorkel masks can range from $29 for basic options to $60 and above for reputable brands. In comparison, traditional masks start around $25 and can go up to approximately $50 for high-quality models.

Q: How are full face snorkel masks perceived by experienced snorkelers? A: Full face snorkel masks are often associated with beginners and may not be well-regarded by experienced snorkelers. Some snorkel tour operators may even prohibit the use of full face snorkel masks on their excursions.

Q: Can full face snorkel masks be used by individuals with physical limitations? A: Yes, full face snorkel masks can be helpful for individuals with physical limitations that prevent them from using traditional masks and snorkels. In such cases, the comfort and confidence provided by full face masks can enhance their ability to enjoy snorkeling.