Ultimate Reciprocating Saw Battle

Ultimate Reciprocating Saw Battle

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction
2. Comparison of Reciprocating Saws 2.1 Craftsman CMC S 350 2.2 Heart HPR-S0111 2.3 Ridgid R 8643 2.4 Makita XRJZ
3. Test 1: Cutting through a Treated 4x4 3.1 Craftsman CMC S 350 3.2 Heart HPR-S0111 3.3 Ridgid R 8643 3.4 Makita XRJZ
4. Test 2: Blade Installation and Removal 4.1 Craftsman CMC S 350 4.2 Heart HPR-S0111 4.3 Ridgid R 8643 4.4 Makita XRJZ
5. Test 3: Cut Count with One Battery Charge 5.1 Craftsman CMC S 350 5.2 Heart HPR-S0111 5.3 Ridgid R 8643 5.4 Makita XRJZ
6. Conclusion
7. Pros and Cons of Each Reciprocating Saw
8. Final Thoughts
9. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Comparison of Reciprocating Saws

Reciprocating saws are versatile tools that are widely used in various industries, including construction, woodworking, and demolition. In this comparison, we will analyze four popular reciprocating saw models: the Craftsman CMC S 350, the Heart HPR-S0111, the Ridgid R 8643, and the Makita XRJZ.

2.1 Craftsman CMC S 350

The Craftsman CMC S 350 is a brushless reciprocating saw that operates on Craftsman's 20-volt battery platform. It features a stroke length of 1 1/8 inches and does not have an orbital action. With a weight of 5.8 pounds and two-speed settings, it offers versatility and ease of use.

2.2 Heart HPR-S0111

The Heart HPR-S0111 is a brushed reciprocating saw that weighs 3.14 pounds. This Chinese-made saw has a stroke length of 7/8 inches and offers a maximum speed of 3,300 strokes per minute. While it may not be as powerful as other models, it provides an affordable option for occasional DIY projects.

2.3 Ridgid R 8643

The Ridgid R 8643 is part of the 18-volt Octane series and is a brushless reciprocating saw. Weighing 6.7 pounds, this saw offers a stroke length of 1 1/8 inches and a maximum speed of 3,100 strokes per minute. With its extended length of 17 5/8 inches, it provides added reach for certain applications.

2.4 Makita XRJZ

The Makita XRJZ is a brushless compact reciprocating saw measuring only 12.5 inches in length. Made in China, it weighs 4.7 pounds and features a stroke length of 13/16 inches. While it may have a shorter stroke length than the other models, its compact design and 18-volt platform make it a popular choice for certain tasks.

Test 1: Cutting through a Treated 4x4

In this test, we will evaluate the cutting performance of each reciprocating saw by measuring how quickly they can cut through a treated 4x4. This test will assess both power and efficiency.

3.1 Craftsman CMC S 350

The Craftsman CMC S 350 showcased impressive cutting speed as it effortlessly sliced through the treated 4x4. With its brushless motor and longer stroke length of 1 1/8 inches, it completed the cut in just 32.03 seconds.

3.2 Heart HPR-S0111

The Heart HPR-S0111 struggled during the test, experiencing frequent bogging down and multiple stops. It managed to complete the cut after 1 minute and 5 seconds, exhibiting its limitations in terms of power and efficiency.

3.3 Ridgid R 8643

Equipped with an orbital function (which was not tested in this video), the Ridgid R 8643 demonstrated exceptional cutting performance, finishing the cut in just 31.27 seconds. Its longer stroke length of 1 1/8 inches contributed to its efficiency.

3.4 Makita XRJZ

Despite having the shortest stroke length of 13/16 inches, the Makita XRJZ showcased decent cutting abilities, completing the cut in 37 seconds. Its compact design and 18-volt platform make it a suitable option for certain tasks where maneuverability is key.

[Continue writing the article Based on the provided Table of Contents]