Unveiling the Controversial Reason Behind Sebastian's Dark Arts in Hogwarts Legacy

Unveiling the Controversial Reason Behind Sebastian's Dark Arts in Hogwarts Legacy

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction
2. The Plight of Anne
3. The Ethics of Forbidden Magic
4. Sebastian's Perspective
5. Solomon's Aversion to Dark Magic
6. Sebastian's Loyalty as a Homie
7. The Catacomb Confrontation
8. Acting in Self-Defense
9. The Decision: Snitch or Stay Silent
10. Anne's Cursed Revelation
11. Sebastian's Shifting Viewpoint
12. Conclusion

Introduction

In this article, we will explore the complex and controversial topic of Sebastian's use of dark arts to save his sister, Anne, in Hogwarts Legacy. While many may argue that Sebastian's actions were wrong and should be reported, there are valid arguments for why he was right in his decision. We will Delve into the ethical implications of forbidden magic, the perspectives of Sebastian and his uncle Solomon, and the loyalty displayed by Sebastian throughout the game. Additionally, we will analyze the catacomb confrontation, examining Sebastian's self-defense and his subsequent decision on whether to snitch or remain silent. Finally, we will uncover the shocking revelation about Anne's curse and its impact on Sebastian's viewpoint.

The Plight of Anne

Anne, Sebastian's sister, is suffering from a powerful curse that inflicts excruciating pain and threatens to shorten her life. Despite visiting numerous healers, no cure has been found. Sebastian, refusing to accept Anne's inevitable fate, believes that exploring forbidden magic is their only hope. This raises a crucial question: should certain forms of magic be forbidden and made illegal solely due to their potential for evil? Sebastian argues that the dark arts label is arbitrary and that if a particular form of magic can be used for good, it should not inherently be deemed as evil.

The Ethics of Forbidden Magic

The debate surrounding the ethics of forbidden magic is one of moral ambiguity. While the potential for abuse and harm is undeniable, every tool has the potential for both good and evil. Sebastian questions whether the killing curse, as an example, is any different from incendio when it comes to eliminating enemies. He argues that magic, like any other tool, is defined by its application and intent. If a Spell is used for noble purposes such as saving a loved one, should it automatically be branded as dark magic? This perspective challenges the rigid categorization of magic and calls for a reconsideration of what defines the dark arts.

Sebastian's Perspective

From Sebastian's perspective, there is no viable cure for Anne's condition within the confines of traditional magic. He sees exploring forbidden magic as the only chance to save his sister. Sebastian embarks on a treacherous Journey through ancient tomes and forgotten catacombs, risking his own well-being in a desperate attempt to find a solution. Sebastian's determination, fueled by love for his sister, raises an important question: would any reasonable person not exhaust all possibilities if faced with the same dire circumstances? Sebastian's quest showcases his unwavering loyalty and dedication to his family, making it difficult to condemn his actions outright.

Solomon's Aversion to Dark Magic

Uncle Solomon, Sebastian's uncle, vehemently opposes the use of dark magic. His strong aversion may stem from personal experiences during his time with the Ministry, alluding to involvement in using unforgivable curses against dark wizards. However, Sebastian doubts whether Solomon would report their use of dark magic to the Ministry, considering his strained relationship with them. Solomon's stance against dark arts and his threat to snitch place him at odds with Sebastian and force us to question the validity of his arguments.

Sebastian's Loyalty as a Homie

Sebastian's loyalty throughout the game further complicates the decision to snitch on him. As the only student who teaches the player character spells, he provides invaluable knowledge and even shares advanced spells typically inaccessible to students. Despite being aware of Sebastian's use of forbidden magic, the player character still benefits from his teachings. This raises the question of whether loyalty and friendship should outweigh the need to report wrongdoing. Sebastian's willingness to keep the player character's secret when they sneaked into the restricted section of the library adds another layer of moral complexity to this situation.

The Catacomb Confrontation

The catacomb confrontation serves as a breaking point in Sebastian's journey. When he taps into the power of a relic discovered in the catacombs, it becomes clear that Sebastian has mastered the summoning and control of dark forces. Ominous, Sebastian's best friend and housemate, expresses his concern and pleads for Sebastian to steer clear of dark magic. However, Sebastian's increasing anger towards goblins and dark wizards, fueled by his encounters and experiences, makes it difficult to predict his next course of action.

Acting in Self-Defense

During the catacomb confrontation, Solomon interrupts and aggressively seizes the relic from Sebastian. Manipulating the situation, he destroys the relic and unleashes a horde of zombies upon Sebastian and the player character. Solomon's actions, coupled with his refusal to support them against the zombies, demonstrate his aggressive stance against dark magic. In such a life-threatening Scenario, where survival is at stake, Sebastian and the player character have no choice but to defend themselves. The question arises: should they be condemned for acting in self-defense?

The Decision: Snitch or Stay Silent

After the catacomb confrontation, Sebastian faces the possibility of being turned in to Professor Black by Ominous. However, considering the circumstances and the impact on Anne, Ominous questions whether snitching on Sebastian would be the right move. Anne has already lost her health and her uncle, and taking her brother away as well could have dire consequences. The decision to snitch or stay silent becomes a moral dilemma, where the potential repercussions need to be weighed against the hope of Anne's eventual recovery.

Anne's Cursed Revelation

As the game progresses, a shocking revelation unfolds: Anne was cursed by Victor Rookwood, a dark magician, and not a goblin as previously believed. Sebastian's viewpoint on goblins undergoes a dramatic shift, as he realizes that his aversion towards them was misplaced. This newfound knowledge adds a layer of complexity to the situation, raising questions about prejudice, biases, and the complexity of judging individuals solely Based on their association with a certain group.

Conclusion

In Hogwarts Legacy, Sebastian's choice to utilize dark arts to save his sister Anne sparks a heated debate about ethical boundaries, loyalty, and the consequences of snitching. While some argue that Sebastian's actions were unforgivable and deserving of punishment, there are valid arguments supporting his decision. The intricacies of personal experiences, loyalty, self-defense, and the revelation about Anne's curse make it challenging to pass a definitive judgment. As players navigate the game's moral dilemma, they are confronted with thought-provoking questions about the boundaries of magic and the complexities of human nature.