The Battle of AI Writers: Google Bard vs ChatGPT
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Comparison between Bard and Chat GPT
- Creative Storytelling
- Coding for Non-Coders
- Business Strategy or Entrepreneurial Design
- Travel Planning
- Research
- Other Comparisons
- Pros and Cons of Bard and Chat GPT
- Conclusion
Introduction
Ever since Google I/O's conference last week, there have been numerous discussions about the superiority of Bard over Chat GPT. In this article, we will Delve into the features and performance of both these language models and compare them across various categories. We will specifically evaluate their capabilities in creative storytelling, coding for non-coders, business strategy or entrepreneurial design, travel planning, and research. Additionally, we will analyze other comparisons and weigh the pros and cons of each model. By the end of this article, You will have a comprehensive understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of Bard and Chat GPT, and be able to make an informed decision on which model suits your needs best.
Comparison between Bard and Chat GPT
In recent discussions, claims have been made about Bard surpassing Chat GPT in terms of performance. To determine the validity of these claims, we conducted a rigorous comparison between the two models in various categories. Our evaluation involved testing them in creative storytelling, coding for non-coders, business strategy or entrepreneurial design, travel planning, and research. By examining their responses and outputs in these areas, we aimed to establish which model outperforms the other. The results of our analysis provide valuable insights into the capabilities of Bard and Chat GPT and shed light on their relative strengths and weaknesses.
Creative Storytelling
Creative storytelling is often seen as one of the key strengths of language models like Bard and Chat GPT. To assess their storytelling abilities, we requested both models to help us write a story about a nine-year-old boy and his dragon best friend, drawing inspiration from classic children's books by renowned authors like Roald Dahl.
Bard's response, although following the prompt to some extent, fell short of our expectations. The story it generated seemed to have been written by a nine-year-old boy, lacking narrative coherence and poetic elements. On the other HAND, Chat GPT produced a well-crafted story titled "The Adventures of Leo and Ember, the Unlikely Duo." It successfully captured the essence of classic children's books, featuring Vivid descriptions and a coherent narrative arc. In terms of creative storytelling, Chat GPT clearly outperformed Bard.
Coding for Non-Coders
The ability to assist non-coders in coding tasks is a highly sought-after feature in language models. We asked both Bard and Chat GPT to help us Create a Website similar to Hacker News, but focused on AI stories. Bard provided a generic response, outlining the basic steps involved, including choosing a domain name, installing a content management system, selecting a theme, creating pages and posts, customizing the website's look and feel, and promoting it. While it covered the essential steps, Bard's response lacked specificity and failed to account for the unique features of Hacker News.
Chat GPT, on the other hand, presented a detailed plan of action, addressing specific requirements such as user registration, posting stories, voting, commenting, and more. It provided recommendations for the tech stack, database design, and even suggested endpoints for user-related actions. The comprehensive and clear roadmap offered by Chat GPT makes it a more reliable choice for non-coders seeking guidance in building a website.
Business Strategy or Entrepreneurial Design
Both Bard and Chat GPT exhibited promising capabilities when it came to business strategy and entrepreneurial design. We asked them to help us create an e-commerce business utilizing Generative AI, with a budget of $1,000. Bard proposed a custom-designed clothing and accessories business, leveraging generative AI for design and marketing. Its steps included researching the target audience, developing a business plan, choosing an e-commerce platform, designing and developing the website, and implementing marketing strategies.
Chat GPT came up with a similar idea, focusing on personalized product design Based on customer preferences. It offered actionable steps, such as creating personalized digital assets, using generative AI to generate unique designs, and recommended budget allocations. While both models provided valuable insights, Chat GPT's detailed suggestions and thorough breakdown of each step gave it an edge in this category.
Travel Planning
Planning a trip is a common use case for language models, as they can assist in creating personalized itineraries. We presented Bard and Chat GPT with a request to create a recommended itinerary for a three-night, two-day trip to Paris in late June. We specified preferences for avoiding lines, having a medium to high budget, enjoying gourmet cuisine, and exploring the city's literary and artistic past.
Bard's response proved to be generic, suggesting a leisurely breakfast in La Marais, an unspecified museum in the afternoon, and a romantic dinner at a Michelin-starred restaurant in Montmartre. In contrast, Chat GPT provided more specific recommendations, including breakfast at a charming cafe in Le Marais, lunch at a Provencal bistro with a charming terrace, and exploring literary landmarks like La Procope and The Shakespearean Company bookstore. Chat GPT's Attention to Detail and ability to curate a tailored itinerary made it the preferred choice for travel planning.
Research
Research is a crucial aspect of language models, as they can assist users in gathering information and understanding complex topics. We evaluated Bard and Chat GPT's research capabilities by asking them about the Nigeria-Biafra Civil War in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Bard presented a summary of the conflict, highlighting international condemnation due to the use of starvation as a weapon. However, it failed to capture the war's significance in the development of international humanitarian aid.
Chat GPT, on the other hand, provided additional insights, including specific incidents and the war's role in the development of international humanitarian law. It correctly acknowledged the war's impact in spurring the creation of principles like "responsibility to protect" and the birth of modern humanitarian aid. With its comprehensive response, Chat GPT demonstrated superior research capabilities compared to Bard.
Other Comparisons
In addition to our specific evaluations, we explored other comparisons conducted by experts and users. These comparisons assessed various aspects like summarization, ethical considerations, small talk abilities, generating formulas, and simplifying text. Overall, the results showed a close competition between Bard and Chat GPT, with each model winning in different categories. While Bard excelled in certain areas like summarizing broad topics, Chat GPT demonstrated strengths in generating creative ideas and simplifying text.
Pros and Cons of Bard and Chat GPT
After thoroughly examining the performance of Bard and Chat GPT across multiple categories, it is important to consider the pros and cons of each.
Bard's advantages include integration with Google Suite tools, enabling seamless exporting of answers into Gmail and Google Docs. It also has the capability to process images as Prompts, which can be beneficial in certain use cases. However, Bard's responses often lack specificity and imagination, diminishing its effectiveness in creative storytelling and providing personalized recommendations.
Chat GPT, on the other hand, presents more comprehensive and detailed responses for various tasks. It possesses a natural Flair for storytelling and offers practical guidance in areas like coding for non-coders, business strategy, travel planning, and research. However, Chat GPT lacks direct integration with popular productivity tools and may require additional steps for seamless workflow integration.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the comparison between Bard and Chat GPT reveals that Chat GPT generally outperforms Bard in categories such as creative storytelling, coding for non-coders, travel planning, and research. Chat GPT consistently provides more detailed and tailored responses, making it a preferred choice in these areas. However, Bard possesses certain unique features such as image processing and integration with Google Suite tools, making it a viable option for users who heavily rely on these functionalities. By considering the specific requirements of your use case and weighing the pros and cons, you can make an informed decision on whether Bard or Chat GPT is better suited for your needs.
Highlights
- Chat GPT outperforms Bard in creative storytelling, coding for non-coders, travel planning, and research.
- Bard has unique features like image processing and integration with Google Suite tools.
- Chat GPT provides more detailed and tailored responses in various categories.
- Consider the specific requirements and functionalities needed to make an informed choice between Bard and Chat GPT.