Acer Nitro 5 vs ASUS TUF A15: Which is the Best Gaming Laptop?

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Display Comparison
3. Memory and Storage Capacity
4. CPU Performance
5. GPU Performance
6. Battery Capacity
7. Thermals
8. Durability
9. Value for Money
10. Conclusion

Introduction

The ASUS Tough Gaming A15 laptop has recently been released with impressive specifications and an attractive price point. With improved cooling systems compared to its predecessors, this new device seems to be a top contender in the mid-budget segment. In order to determine whether this new Tough Gaming laptop can surpass the reliable Acer Nitro 5, which was launched earlier in 2021, we have conducted a head-to-head comparison between the RTX 3060 versions of these devices. This article will provide an in-depth analysis and help you decide which gaming laptop is the better option for your needs.

Display Comparison

Both the ASUS Tough Gaming A15 and the Acer Nitro 5 laptops feature a standard 15.6-inch Full HD screen with a 144Hz refresh rate. They both offer 45 percent NTSC color coverage and an average brightness level of 250 nits. The Nitro 5 provides a color reproduction of 62% sRGB and a screen response time of 19 milliseconds. On the other HAND, the Tough Gaming A15 offers a color reproduction of 63.2% sRGB and a screen response time of 8 milliseconds. While the display on both devices is quite similar, the Tough Gaming A15 provides a slightly better display experience.

Memory and Storage Capacity

The Nitro 5 offers 16GB of RAM and 256GB of SSD storage, along with 1TB of hard drive storage. The memory is also upgradable to up to 32GB and the laptop has an additional SSD slot for future upgradability. On the other hand, the Tough Gaming A15 comes with 16GB of RAM, consisting of dual-Channel 8GB RAM sticks, and 512GB of SSD storage. The memory is also upgradable to up to 32GB and the laptop offers 1TB of SSD storage. Both devices provide ample memory and storage capacity, but the Nitro 5 has the advantage of additional hard drive storage.

CPU Performance

Both laptops are equipped with AMD's latest 5000 series processors, which are based on AMD's Zen 3 architecture and built on a 7-nanometer fabrication. The Tough Gaming A15 is powered by the Ryzen 7 5800H processor, which features 8 cores and 16 Threads, with a base clock of 3.2 GHz and up to 4.4 GHz boost clock speeds, and a TDP of 54 watts. Based on benchmarking results, the Tough Gaming A15 achieved an overall benchmark score of 24.7 points. On the other hand, the Acer Nitro 5 is equipped with the AMD Ryzen 5 5600H processor, which features 6 cores and 12 threads, with a base clock of 3.3 GHz and a boost clock of 4.2 GHz, and a TDP of 45 watts. The Nitro 5 achieved an overall benchmark score of 20.2 points. The comparison between these two processors reveals that the Ryzen 7 5800H chip in the Tough Gaming A15 delivers approximately 23% better performance compared to the Ryzen 5 5600H chip in the Nitro 5.

GPU Performance

The RTX 3060 graphics card found in both laptops is based on NVIDIA's Ampere architecture and manufactured using an 8-nanometer fabrication process. It features 3840 CUDA cores, a 95-watt TGP, and 6GB of graphics memory. In terms of gaming performance, the FPS results of both laptops were tested in various gaming titles. The Nitro 5 with RTX 3060 produced an average FPS of 61.5 at 1080p resolution, while the Tough Gaming A15 achieved an average FPS of 61.2. Therefore, you can expect almost similar gaming performance from both laptops.

Battery Capacity

The Tough Gaming A15 is equipped with a 90-watt-hour battery, which offers up to 11 hours of regular usage and approximately 2 hours of gaming. On the other hand, the Nitro 5 has a smaller 57.5-watt-hour battery, which provides up to 4.5 hours of normal usage and less than one hour of gaming. The Tough Gaming A15's battery offers better longevity, making it more suitable for extended periods of use. However, for optimal GPU performance, it is recommended to keep the laptop plugged in.

Thermals

During load, the Nitro 5 reaches a maximum temperature of 45 degrees Celsius on the laptop surface. On the other hand, the Tough Gaming A15 reaches a maximum temperature of 50 degrees Celsius under heavy workload. Both laptops have decent thermal management, with minor regions getting warm during demanding tasks. However, the fan noise on both laptops is noticeable under high-performance settings, with the Nitro 5 being slightly louder.

Durability

The Nitro 5 offers a better keyboard and trackpad experience compared to the Tough Gaming A15. However, the Tough Gaming A15's military-based build feels more Durable than the Nitro 5's full plastic build. If durability is a priority for you, the Tough Gaming A15 may be a better choice.

Value for Money

Both laptops offer great value for money, but when comparing the two, the Tough Gaming A15 provides better battery backup and superior multi-core performance. If you require a laptop for tasks such as video editing or graphic designing, the Tough Gaming A15's multi-core capabilities make it the preferable choice. However, if you prioritize good gaming performance for everyday tasks, the affordable Nitro 5 might be the better option.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the ASUS Tough Gaming A15 and the Acer Nitro 5 are both excellent gaming laptops. However, the Tough Gaming A15 stands out with its better battery backup and superior multi-core performance. If you need a laptop for demanding tasks like video editing or graphic designing, the Tough Gaming A15 is the recommended choice. On the other hand, if you prioritize gaming performance for everyday tasks, the Nitro 5 provides a more affordable option. Ultimately, the decision depends on your specific needs and budget.

Highlights

• The ASUS Tough Gaming A15 offers improved cooling systems and impressive specifications at an attractive price point.
• The head-to-head comparison between the Tough Gaming A15 and the Acer Nitro 5 helps determine the better option.
• The display comparison shows similar displays, but the Tough Gaming A15 provides a slightly better experience.
• Both laptops have ample memory and storage capacity, with the Nitro 5 offering additional hard drive storage.
• The Tough Gaming A15's Ryzen 7 5800H processor delivers better multi-core performance compared to the Nitro 5's Ryzen 5 5600H chip.
• The RTX 3060 graphics card offers similar gaming performance in both laptops.
• The Tough Gaming A15's 90-watt-hour battery offers better longevity compared to the Nitro 5.
• Both laptops have decent thermal management, with the Tough Gaming A15 reaching slightly higher temperatures under load.
• The Tough Gaming A15's military-based build provides better durability compared to the Nitro 5's full plastic build.
• The Tough Gaming A15 provides better value for money with its superior multi-core performance and battery backup.

FAQ

Q: Does the ASUS Tough Gaming A15 have better gaming performance than the Acer Nitro 5? A: The gaming performance of both laptops is similar, with both the Tough Gaming A15 and Nitro 5 delivering comparable FPS in gaming titles.

Q: Can I upgrade the memory and storage capacity of the ASUS Tough Gaming A15? A: Yes, the memory of the Tough Gaming A15 is upgradable to up to 32GB, and it also has an additional SSD slot for future upgradability.

Q: Which laptop offers better battery backup, the Tough Gaming A15 or the Nitro 5? A: The Tough Gaming A15 has a larger battery capacity, offering up to 11 hours of regular usage compared to the Nitro 5's shorter battery life.

Q: Does the Tough Gaming A15 get hot during demanding tasks? A: The Tough Gaming A15 does reach higher temperatures under load, but it has decent thermal management to prevent overheating.

Q: Which laptop is more suitable for video editing or graphic designing? A: The Tough Gaming A15's superior multi-core performance makes it the recommended choice for tasks like video editing or graphic designing.

Resources:

• ASUS Tough Gaming A15
• Acer Nitro 5