Is Intel or AMD Better for Gaming? A Competitive Setting Battle

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction
2. Comparison of Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K
3. Performance Analysis with Low Quality Settings
4. Battlefield 5 Performance Comparison
5. Rocket League Performance Comparison
6. Counter-Strike: Global Offensive Performance Comparison
7. Rainbow Six Siege Performance Comparison
8. PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds Performance Comparison
9. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Performance Comparison
10. Fortnite Performance Comparison
11. World of Tanks Performance Comparison
12. War Thunder Performance Comparison
13. Overall Performance Analysis
14. Conclusion

Article:

Introduction

Welcome back to Harbor Unbox! Today, we are going to compare the performance of the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K processors in various games. However, we will focus on low or competitive quality settings in games like Fortnite, Rocket League, and other competitive titles. It is important to note that the frame rates will be significantly different compared to the high and ultra quality presets used in our CPU reviews, where we test with demanding games like Shadow of the Tomb Raider, Battlefield 5, and Red Dead Redemption 2.

Comparison of Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K

In this comparison, we aim to determine the performance differences between the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K processors. While reviewing the Core i5 10 600K, we found that it was on average 5% faster than the Horizon 730 700X at 1080p, but the margin might slightly grow in more CPU-limited scenarios like playing tile-based games such as Fortnite with competitive quality settings. As a result, we recommended the Intel processor for those who prioritize squeezing out every last frame possible. However, for everyone else, we believe that the Horizon 730 700X offers better value and a more well-rounded product.

Performance Analysis with Low Quality Settings

For this performance analysis, we focused on testing low quality settings in our games. It is important to mention that the GPU often limits the performance, even with a high-end graphics card like the GeForce RTX 2080 Ti, as most gamers with such a graphics card would play modern triple-A titles at 1440p with high-quality settings.

Battlefield 5 Performance Comparison

With the low quality preset enabled, we tested the performance in Battlefield 5 at both 1080p and 1440p. Surprisingly, both the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K reached a similar frame rate, with the GPU being the performance limiting component. When using the higher quality settings, the margin between the two processors grew slightly, but it is important to note that both processors delivered well over 200 FPS at all times.

Rocket League Performance Comparison

In Rocket League, we tested the performance at 1080p and 1440p with low quality settings. With the frame cap removed, the Core i5 10 600K outperformed the Horizon 730 700X, boosting the 1% low performance by almost 40% and the average frame rate by 24%. However, it is worth noting that both processors delivered well over 200 FPS at all times, and the margin became irrelevant when using a more realistic GPU for this title.

Counter-Strike: Global Offensive Performance Comparison

In Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CSGO), we observed a strong CPU bottleneck with both the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K, as the frame rates were virtually identical when using the RTX 2080 Ti and RTX 2060 Super. Surprisingly, the Horizon 730 700X was actually faster than the Core i5 10 600K, delivering 8% better average performance and 22% stronger 1% lows.

Rainbow Six Siege Performance Comparison

In Rainbow Six Siege, we compared the performance of the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K at low quality settings. While using the RTX 2080 Ti, the performance was almost identical, with a slight advantage for the Horizon 730 700X in terms of average framerate and 1% low data. When using the RTX 2060 Super, there was a 7% performance advantage for the Horizon 730 700X. It is important to note that both processors enabled over 250 FPS at all times with these competitive settings.

PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds Performance Comparison

PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds (PUBG) performed better with Intel CPUs when using higher quality settings. With the low quality preset enabled, there was no difference between the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K when using the RTX 2080 Ti, as both processors delivered similar performance and well above 200 FPS at all times. When using the RTX 2060 Super, there was still no margin between the two processors.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Performance Comparison

When testing Call of Duty: Modern Warfare with low quality settings, both CPUs performed competitively, and even pro gamers wouldn't be able to tell the difference. The Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K delivered similar frame rates and average performance, with a minor advantage for the Core i5 10 600K when comparing the 1% low data. It is important to note that both processors enabled over 200 FPS at all times.

Fortnite Performance Comparison

In Fortnite, both the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K performed well with low quality settings. The Core i5 10 600K was faster, but it's important to question the usefulness of that extra performance, especially considering the Game's 250 FPS cap. The performance advantage of the Core i5 10 600K became irrelevant when using a more realistic GPU. Both processors delivered well over 200 FPS at all times.

World of Tanks Performance Comparison

World of Tanks performance analysis showed a strong CPU bottleneck, with both the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K delivering similar performance when using the RTX 2080 Ti and RTX 2060 Super. The Core i5 10 600K was up to 13% faster, but going well over 200 FPS may not be beneficial for most gamers. The results remained consistent at 1440p, with similar numbers and well over 200 FPS at all times.

War Thunder Performance Comparison

War Thunder results demonstrated extreme frame rates, making the margins between the Horizon 730 700X and Core i5 10 600K irrelevant. Both processors were heavily CPU-bound, delivering well over 350 FPS at all times. Similarly, at 1440p, the Core i5 10 600K was up to 14% faster, but the difference may not have a significant impact on gameplay.

Overall Performance Analysis

When analyzing the average performance across all nine games tested, the Core i5 10 600K was 10% faster than the Horizon 730 700X when using the RTX 2080 Ti, and 2% faster with the RTX 2060 Super. However, it is important to consider the diminishing returns when going beyond 200 FPS. For most gamers, the performance differences between these two processors may be largely irrelevant.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Core i5 10 600K is the faster gaming CPU, but the performance differences compared to the Horizon 730 700X are minimal. The extra performance offered by the Core i5 10 600K may not be noticeable for the majority of gamers, especially when considering the 250 FPS cap in many games. The Horizon 730 700X provides better value and a more well-rounded product, particularly with its stronger productivity performance. It is also worth noting that the Intel processors may not remain the fastest gaming CPUs in the future. Ultimately, the decision should be based on individual needs and priorities.

Highlights:

• The Core i5 10 600K is the faster gaming CPU, but the margin compared to the Horizon 730 700X is minimal.
• Performance differences between the two processors may not be noticeable for most gamers, especially when considering the 250 FPS cap in many games.
• The Horizon 730 700X offers better value and a more well-rounded product, with stronger productivity performance.
• The performance advantage of the Core i5 10 600K may not be Relevant in three years' time.
• Individual needs and priorities should guide the decision between the two processors.

FAQ:

Q: Is the Core i5 10 600K significantly better than the Horizon 730 700X for gaming? A: The Core i5 10 600K is indeed the faster gaming CPU, but the performance margin compared to the Horizon 730 700X is minimal. Most gamers may not notice the difference in real-world gaming scenarios.

Q: Does the 250 FPS cap in many games make the extra performance of the Core i5 10 600K irrelevant? A: Yes, the 250 FPS cap limits the practical benefits of the extra performance offered by the Core i5 10 600K. It may not significantly improve the gaming experience for most players.

Q: Does the Horizon 730 700X provide better value overall? A: Yes, the Horizon 730 700X offers better value and a more well-rounded product, especially with its stronger productivity performance. It is a more balanced choice for users seeking both gaming and productivity capabilities.

Q: Will the Intel processors remain the fastest gaming CPUs in the future? A: There is no guarantee that the Intel processors will remain the fastest gaming CPUs in the future. Technological advancements and newer processor generations may change the landscape of gaming performance.